Libel and Malicious Falsehood Claim Dismissed over Insufficient Evidence Linking Defendant to Defamatory Google Reviews

Written By

tom moore Module
Tom Moore

Senior Associate
UK

I am a senior associate in our Dispute Resolution group in London specialising in defamation, reputation protection and crisis management, as well commercial disputes, particularly in the media, entertainment, sport and tech sectors.

Samuels t/a Samuels & Co Solicitors v Henry [2024] EWHC 2898 (KB)

A “litigant may not sit on their hands”: Deputy Master Marzec rejected a belated request to stay proceedings and dismissed a libel and malicious falsehood claim, finding insufficient evidence to link the defendant to defamatory reviews posted on the claimant’s Google Business Profile. Lack of evidence and the failure to determine the author of the defamatory statements ultimately led to the dismissal of the claim.

The Claim

Jacqueline Samuels, a sole practitioner trading as Samuels & Co Solicitors, claimed her former client, Christopher John Henry, posted three malicious and defamatory reviews on her Google Business Profile using Gmail accounts named "Chris H", "John H" and "P.R.". The defendant denied authorship on oath and sought to have the claims struck out. The court was required to determine, as a preliminary issue, whether the defendant was responsible for publishing the material.

The Claimant’s Failure to Take Decisive Action

The claimant sought to link the defendant to the reviews on two primary bases: 

(a) the similarity of the names “Chris H” and “John H” to the defendant’s full name; and 

(b) the fact that none of her other clients had names that could…

Full article available on Disputes +

Latest insights

More Insights
featured image

France's Ministry of Justice Initiates Task Force to Reform French Arbitration Law

9 minutes May 29 2025

Read More
Curiosity line teal background

China Cybersecurity and Data Protection: Monthly Update - May 2025 Issue

May 26 2025

Read More
Curiosity line yellow background

New AI Content Labelling Rules in China: What are they and how do they compare to the EU AI Act?

9 minutes May 20 2025

Read More