Bird & Bird has won a court battle for the European Commission on the question of jurisdiction of national courts in trademark infringement proceedings against EU institutions.
The Regional Court of Düsseldorf had initially issued an interim injunction against the European Commission for alleged infringement of an EU trademark by way of urgent legal protection. The decision was initially made unilaterally and by way of resolution, i.e. without the participation of the European Commission.
The European Commission objected to this, claiming, among other things, that the national courts of the Member States do not have jurisdiction under the rules of the EU Treaties in proceedings in which claims are brought against EU institutions. Such claims must be brought before the courts of the European Union in Luxembourg.
In a ruling now published (ref. 34 O 8/21), the Düsseldorf Regional Court decided that it had no jurisdiction over the matter and revoked its own interim injunction. The Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) provides that only the Union courts may rule on actions for damages in the area of non-contractual liability of the European Union or one of its institutions. The concept of damages is to be interpreted broadly in accordance with the meaning and purpose of the provision, and covers the entire area of non-contractual liability, and thus also claims for injunctive relief.
This also applies to proceedings for interim relief. The European courts may also issue interim measures. The exclusive jurisdiction to issue interim measures against an institution of the European Union necessarily follows from the rule on jurisdiction for non-contractual liability.
The European Commission was represented by the following Bird & Bird lawyers: partner Dr. Richard Dissmann and associate Dr. Laura Jones, both Intellectual Property/Litigation, Munich. The case was referred to the German team by the Brussels-based relationship partner Jean-Christophe Troussel.
Bird & Bird named Hungarian Law Firm of the Year at Chambers Europe Awards 2023
May 26 2023
Bird & Bird secures AGCM acceptance of important commitments on behalf of public railway incumbent Trenitalia
May 09 2023
Bird & Bird is proud to have provided legal assistance to NNIT in a complex divestment of its infrastructure operations business transaction
May 03 2023