By
08-2007
There was no claim in the USA against UK-based employees even though their bonus agreements were expressed to be subject to US law.The Court of Appeal has recently had to consider an EU Regulation (EC) 44/2001 which requires that, in matters relating to individual contracts of employment of EU employees, employers may bring legal proceedings only in the EU Member State in which the employee is domiciled.This overrides anything that may be said in the contract itself.This question arose for decision in the case of Samengo-Turner and others v Marsh & McLennan. The EU-domiciled employees were insurance brokers working for a UK company which was part of a group of companies. The employees had entered into bonus agreements with the holding company which was based in New York.The bonus agreements provided for cash awards payable by instalments which could be repaid in the event of the employee engaging in ‘detrimental activity’ and were expressed to be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the New York Courts. When the employees disclosed that they intended to leave and work for a competitor, the holding company instituted Court proceedings in New York alleging that they employees had engaged in ‘detrimental activity’ and seeking repayment of awards under the bonus agreement.The employees sought an injunction from the UK Courts to prevent the New York claim from proceeding, claiming that the EU Regulation applied.The High Court Judge who initially heard their claim considered that he could not make such an order because the New York holding company was not their employer and the bonus agreements were therefore not ‘individual contracts of employment’.The Court of Appeal has now allowed their appeal and made an order staying the New York Court proceedings. The bonus agreement related to, and indeed was part of, the individual’s contract of employment. The employment contract need not be made in one document or at one time. Thus, the EU Regulation overrode the jurisdiction clause in the bonus agreement and claims under that agreement could only be made against the employees in the UK Courts.Points to note:
Partner UK
You can search by keyword, sector or practice area and then optionally filter by a location
Keywords Sector Aerospace, Defence & Security Unmanned Aircraft Systems Automotive Aviation Aircraft Finance Energy & Utilities Renewables Energy Management Energy Network and Transmission Energy Digitalisation Energy Storage Nuclear Oil & Gas Mining and Minerals Financial Services Retail and Consumer Consumer law Food & Beverage Food & Beverage Regulatory Hotels & Leisure Luxury, Fashion and Retail Food & Beverage Regulatory Digest Wellness Life Sciences and Healthcare Life Sciences Healthcare Technology & Communications Communications Devices and Components Digital Technology Solutions, Internet Services and eCommerce Software and Services Data Centres Postal Satellite and Space activities Media, Entertainment and Sport Broadcasting Publishing Gambling Games Marketing Music Social Sport Practice Area Banking & Finance Commercial Competition & EU Law Corporate Capital Markets Mergers & Acquisitions Private Equity Venture Capital Dispute Resolution Commercial Disputes International Arbitration Franchising International Education Infrastructure Intellectual Property Brands Copyright & related rights Patents Product design Transactional IP International HR Services Employment Employee Incentives and Benefits Business Immigration Outsourcing Privacy and Data Protection Data breach and Security Incidents E-Privacy Directive GDPR EU-US Privacy Shield Product compliance and liability Regulatory & Public Affairs Public Projects and Procurement Real Estate Construction and engineering Regulatory and Administrative Restructuring and Insolvency Tax Business Tax Advisory Services and Transfer Pricing Indirect Tax Personal Tax Tax Disputes Tech Transactions Trade and Customs Customs EU Trade Defence Export Controls, Sanctions and Embargoes Trade Regulatory In Focus The Internet of Things 5G Australia's Notifiable Data Breach Scheme Autonomous Driving Blockchain Brexit EU Legislation Tracker Glossary of terms used in relation to Brexit Cloud Computing Compliance & Investigations Cybersecurity Esports FinTech General Data Protection Regulation Geo-Blocking Guide to IP rights in the UK In focus International Expansion Life Sciences Medical Devices Mobile Health Navigating Hong Kong's Competition Law OTT Reports of Trade Mark Cases for CIPA Journal The EU Trade Mark Reform - The biggest change to trade mark law for 20 years Trade Secrets The Unitary Patent and the Unified Patent Court Unmanned Aerial Systems
Location Africa Asia-Pacific Australia Belgium Central and Eastern Europe China Czech Republic & Slovakia Denmark Finland France Germany Hungary India Israel Italy Japan Latin America Luxembourg Middle East Netherlands Nordic Region North America Poland Russia and the CIS Singapore Southeast Europe and Turkey Spain Sweden Switzerland and Austria UK United Arab Emirates United States Western Europe Go
Looking for news over 5 years old?
RT @twobirdsIP: Our Trade Mark Directive Tracker: All major changes to national trade mark law in one map https://t.co/72CQDDRsA4 https://t…
Partner Jonathan Taylor speaks to @thetimes today about the Caster Semenya case, ahead of Court of Arbitration of S… https://t.co/MmmtBtuvoy