Food-Law-Digest.jpg
FOOD0009_WEB_590X200_jpg.jpg

Welcome

In this edition of Bird & Bird's Food Law Digest we guide you through most recent legal developments in Europe and Asia: On the European level we look at EFSA's assessments of "general function" claims and proposed legislation on food information to consumers adopted by the European Commission. The European Court of Justice has ruled on "Cognac" and Finnish trade marks. In China we report on consultation regarding measures for recall of health food products. In Sweden, Czech Republic and Italy, antitrust authorities and courts have made significant decisions, while in Germany, a hygiene barometer for restaurants is in discussion. The Hungarian Parliament accepted a new "chips tax" (public health product fee), and pudding is the content of an interesting Dutch court's judgment. Furthermore we include decisions taken in Italy and Poland concerning advertising and labelling. From the UK, we provide thoughts about packaging measures for cigarettes.
 
We are now planning a seminar in Brussels on 29 September 2011 where we will discuss recent developments in competition and regulatory law. Please find details under "Events" and register for this seminar.


We hope you will enjoy reading this selection of interesting and informative articles!
 
Ulf Grundmann and Armand Killan
Editors and Joint Heads of the Food and Beverage Group  


Belgium

 

Health Claims: the EFSA has finalized the assessment of the "general function" claims
Isabelle Dupuis and Nicolas Carbonnelle

Health Claims have increasingly been used by the food industry, both as an information tool for the customers and as a marketing tool intended to advertise the specific merits and health or nutrition interests of products.


China


Draft Administrative Measures for Recall of Health Food Products under Consultation

Ai-Leen Lim

Food safety has become one of the highest non-economic national priorities in China. From melamine-contaminated milk to artificial eggs made of chemicals, the issue of tainted food calls for urgent attention. 


Czech Republic

Antimonopoly Office - First decision concerning abuse of dominant market power
Andrea Jarolimkova

As we communicated in Food Law Digests in 2010, a new Act on the significant market power in the sale of agricultural products and groceries and on its abuse ("Act") took effect in the Czech Republic on 1 February 2010.

 

Return to top


Germany

 

Proposed hygiene barometer for German restaurants – a modern pillory?

Jarste Akkermann, Frankfurt

The food industry is facing more and more restrictions and constraints by legislation whether it be labelling or health claims, but now gastronomy is also confronted with additional challenges in Germany.

 

European Commission adopts proposed legislation on food information to consumers

Jarste Akkermann, Frankfurt

On 06 July 2011 the European Commission adopted a proposal on the provision of food information to consumers. The core of the proposed revision will be that nutrition labelling becomes mandatory. Nutrition labelling on foods is regulated by Directive 90/496/EEC and currently, under EU legislation, nutrition labelling is optional, although it becomes compulsory when a nutrition or health claim is made in the labelling, presentation or advertising of a foodstuff or when vitamins or minerals are voluntarily added to foods.


Hungary

 

Hungary imposes public product fee for unhealthy food and beverage products (Chips Tax)

Andrea Simándi, Ildikó Scholz, Bálint Halász

On 11 July 2011 the Hungarian Parliament accepted the Public Health Product Fee Act , more commonly referred to as "chips tax". The legislation targets food and beverage products which are considered to be unhealthy – those high in fat, sugar, salt and caffeine - in a effort to stem consumption of these products and boost funding for public health services. The legislation will enter into force on 1 September 2011.

 

New legislation on genetically modified seeds in Hungary

Andrea Simándi, Ildikó Scholz, Bálint Halász

On 14 July 2011, after discovery of maize fields polluted with genetically modified organisms (GMOs), the Ministry of Rural Development passed an amendment of the decree concerning genetically modified seeds. The amendment entered into force on 15 July 2011. The government has stated that the purpose of the amendment is to maintain the GMO-free status of Hungary.

 

Hungarian Parliament establishes committee to investigate sugar industry privatisation

Andrea Simándi, Ildikó Scholz, Bálint Halász

On 14 July 2011 the Hungarian Parliament established a committee to investigate privatisation of the Hungarian sugar industry. The committee of 16 members, who convene on a weekly basis, are tasked with investigating the privatisation of twelve Hungarian sugar factories in the 1990s. 

 

Return to top


Italy

 

Antitrust law in the pasta sector

Licia Garotti, Linda Brugioni

A steaming dish of pasta is not just a symbol of Italian cuisine. Pasta means a lot for the Italian economy, as well as for Italian gourmets.


Unsurprisingly, Italy is one of the leading producers and the main consumer of pasta worldwide (26 kg per year for each individual – Source: UNIPI) and as a consequence, the Italian pasta market is worth a great deal of money.

 

Decisions on food advertising claims

Licia Garotti, Linda Brugioni

With two decisions issued on May 24, 2011, the Italian Competition Authority ascertained that the use of the advertising claims "0,001 cholesterol" or "Soy 0,001% cholesterol" on the packaging of biscuits produced by two Italian companies constitute infringement of both Article 20 and followings of the Italian Consumer Code on unfair commercial practices and the Regulation EC/1924/2006 on nutrition and health claims made on foods.


The Netherlands

 

The proof is in the pudding

Lara van Huizen & Manon Rieger-Jansen

On July 6th the District Court of Utrecht rendered a decision in a tasteful case regarding registered shape marks for pudding packaging.

Return to top


Poland

 

The Office of Competition and Consumers' Protection decides on misleading labelling

Krzysztof Korwin-Kossakowski, Emilia Stępień

Agros Nova, one of the biggest Polish producers of fruit preserves and ready-made food, was punished for misleading labelling on its ready-made food sold under the brand Łowicz.

 

Growing use and investment in renewable energy in the food sector

Krzysztof Korwin-Kossakowski, Emilia Stępień

The Polish food and beverage sector has been increasingly investing in and using renewable energy. Food and beverage producers are seeking ways to optimise their waste and energy management and use new technologies to utilise waste in order to produce energy.  One of the leaders in the field is the Tychy brewery, a member of the international SABMiller Group which has the goal of reducing CO2 emissions by 50% in the next 8 years.  Currently 15% of Tychy brewery's production is powered by heat obtained from biogas produced in its own wastewater treatment plant.


Sweden

 

Competition essentially functioning well in the Swedish food market

David Nilsson, Stockholm

The Swedish Competition Authority ("SCA") recently presented two reports on the functioning of the food supply chain in Sweden.  The reports were prepared following an assignment from the Swedish Government to examine competition and other market conditions in the food supply chain in Sweden. The full reports are available on the website of the SCA (in Swedish).  This article sets out the main conclusions from the report addressing the food supply chain (the other report being focused on public procurement in the food market). 

 

Return to top


UK

 

Geographical indications of spirit drinks (joined cases of C-4/10 andC-27/10) – the CJEU holds that Finnish trade marks must be invalidated

Mary Smillie

Cognac is a protected geographical indication of spirit drinks under Regulation (EC) No. 110/2008  ("the Regulation").  Cognac is made in the area around the town of Cognac in mid-west France.  It is a double-distilled spirit made according to strict regulations.  

 

Plain packaging measures for cigarettes – a violation of the UK's obligations under TRIPS and the Paris Convention

Katharine Stephens

The UK Government intends to "consult on options to reduce the promotional impact of tobacco packaging, including plain packaging" for cigarettes before the end of 2011.  This follows hot on the heels of the Australian Government's recent introduction of a bill on plain packaging which is currently being considered by the House of Representatives. 


Events

 

Seminar Invitation


Food & Beverages: recent developments in competition and regulatory law
 
Brussels, 29 September 2011
 
We'd be delighted if you could join us for an in-depth seminar on competition and regulatory developments affecting the sector across the EU.
 
The seminar will be presented by a team from across Bird & Bird's European offices, and is designed for in-house lawyers, sales teams, product development teams and related business professionals.
 
We'll ensure plenty of time for Q&A and discussion, and please do stay for our networking get-together afterwards.  
 
Please click here for a detailed agenda. 

 

To register for this event, please click here


Contact us

 

Jean-Christophe Troussel Belgium jean.christophe.troussel@twobirds.com
Ai-Leen Lim China and Hong Kong ai-leen.lim@twobirds.com
Miloslav Sinfeld Czech Republic

miloslav.sinfeld@twobirds.com   

Tom Vapaavuori Finland

tom.vapaavuori@twobirds.com

Yves Bizollon France

yves.bizollon@twobirds.com

Ulf Grundmann Germany ulf.grundmann@twobirds.com
Andrea Simandi Hungary

andrea.simandi@twobirds.com

Giovanni Galimberti Italy giovanni.galimberti@twobirds.com
Armand Killan The Netherlands armand.killan@twobirds.com
Emilia Stepien Poland emilia.stepien@twobirds.com
Karol Goh Singapore karol.goh@twobirds.com
Miloslav Sinfeld Slovakia miloslav.sinfeld@twobirds.com
Antonio Creus Spain          antonio.creus@twobirds.com   
Sara Sparring Sweden   sara.sparring@twobirds.com
Jane Mutimear UK jane.mutimear@twobirds.com


 


The content of this update is of general interest and is not intended to apply to specific circumstances. The content should not, therefore, be regarded as constituting legal advice and should not be relied on as such. In relation to any particular problem which they may have, readers are advised to seek specific advice. Further, the law may have changed since first publication and the reader is cautioned accordingly.

BIRD & BIRD

Bird & Bird is an international legal practice comprising Bird & Bird LLP and its affiliated and associated businesses. Bird & Bird LLP is a limited liability partnership, registered in England and Wales with registered number OC340318 and is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Its registered office and principal place of business is at 15 Fetter Lane, London EC4A 1JP.

For details of Bird & Bird, our offices, our members, the use of e-mail and regulatory information, please see twobirds.com and, in particular, twobirds.com/english/Legal_Notices.cfm.

The word "partner" is used to refer to a member of Bird & Bird LLP or an employee or consultant, or to a partner, member, director, employee or consultant in any of its affiliated businesses, who has equivalent standing and qualifications. A list of members of Bird & Bird LLP and of any non-members who are designated as partners, and of their respective professional qualifications, is open to inspection at our London office address.

All such persons are solicitors, registered foreign lawyers or non-registered European lawyers.